I use all three too. Mutts are super cute, but they're a shorter rise (especially the OS, the larges are OK); I think they'd be better for newborns but might not last all the way to PLing, especially for bigger babies. They're the cheapest, but also the least absorbent of the three.
Goodmamas... they're lovely, but I find them a bit poofy
and the exposed snaps really bother me - I've taken one off Lili before to find a whole row of red circles on her tummy
. That said, sometimes they don't leave any marks, and they're soooo pretty that although I've sold most of mine I can't bear to part with them all. I'm actually really liking the all OBV ones right now, even though at first I only looked at the prints. The absorbency is good, but not out of this world.
I'm a huge Bububebe advocate
. They're trim-fitting, by far the most customizable of the three (3 soakers that can be snapped in front or back and folded if necessary), very absorbent, and come in lovely prints and even minkee outers. I think the OBV inners are probably a bit more absorbent than cotton velour, they last us AGES. Like twinkletot said, on the highest rise setting you can snap the soakers in the front, so they cover up the snaps that dig in on a Goodmama. I also think they'll fit the longest.
I agree, best to try them all
- I keep a couple of Mutts and a couple of Goodmamas, but I love my Bububebes best.