Juliette or sheepy skirty?

I need to make a skirty for Grace but can't decide between these patterns. I used to have the sheepy pattern before my laptop died & I liked having so many patterns but have only ever done soakerless ones so not sure how easy the soakered ones are. Like the look of the Juliette but think G will PT this summer

What would you recommend or is there another one I'm missing?

I prefer the Juliette, I like the fact the soaker is slim and not bubbly around the bum but that only gives you the ruffle or a-line options in the pattern.

The soaker ones are dead easy you just pick up stitches on the point where you want the skirt to start so if you know how to do a particular style skirt then you don't even need a pattern